Introduction
John Deere has been building excavators for more than 40 years, and its compact lineup runs from a 1.7-tonne micro machine that squeezes through a gate to a 6.1-tonne flagship that can take down a barn. Six models span that range โ the 17, 26, 30, 35, 50, and 60 โ and unlike some competitors, John Deere makes one big decision for you: nearly every machine is built with reduced or zero tail swing by design, so they’re all suited to close-quarters work. That simplifies the choice, but it doesn’t eliminate it. You still need to match size to your digging depth, decide whether you need the smoother hydraulics of the larger machines, and navigate John Deere’s transition from “G-Series” to “P-Tier” naming. For a Saskatchewan farmer running drainage, an Alberta acreage owner digging footings, or a prairie contractor on tight residential lots, this guide works through those decisions.
We’ll cover the questions that actually narrow the field โ size and dig depth, the hydraulics difference that separates the small machines from the large, tail swing, and attachments โ pointing you to every John Deere compact excavator model along the way, and finish with a full comparison table you can scan in one pass. We’ll also explain the naming change so you know exactly what you’re buying, new or used.
The quick version: most prairie operations doing real digging land on the zero-tail-swing 35 P-Tier โ one of the most popular compact excavators in its class โ or step up to the 50 P-Tier when they need more muscle and smoother attachment hydraulics. Let’s work through it.
First, Understand the Naming: G-Series vs P-Tier
Before anything else, clear up the naming, because you’ll see both on the market and it causes real confusion.
John Deere is transitioning its entire equipment lineup โ excavators included โ from the old “G-Series” designation (17G, 26G, 35G, and so on) to a new “P-Tier” naming (17 P-Tier, 26 P-Tier, 35 P-Tier). Here’s what matters for buyers: for a given size, the G and P-Tier machines refer to essentially the same excavator. A 35G and a 35 P-Tier are the same 3.6-tonne, zero-tail-swing, 10-foot-dig-depth machine; dealers currently sell both side by side as the transition plays out. The P-Tier versions carry the latest cab and technology updates, but the core machine, size class, and capability are the same.
For used buyers, this is good news: a used “35G” is the same machine now sold as the “35 P-Tier,” so don’t let the naming throw you. Throughout this guide we use the current P-Tier names, noting the G equivalent. Now let’s find your machine.
What John Deere Decides for You: Reduced Tail Swing by Design
Here’s where John Deere’s approach differs from some competitors, and it simplifies your decision.
Tail swing describes how far the rear of the machine โ the counterweight and engine housing โ extends past the tracks when the upper structure rotates. A conventional machine’s counterweight swings well past the tracks (more stability, but you watch the rear near walls); a zero-tail-swing machine keeps the rear within the tracks (work flush against obstacles).
Some brands split their lineup into tight-tail and conventional series, making you choose. John Deere instead builds reduced or zero tail swing into nearly every compact machine by design. The smaller 17 and 26 use reduced tail swing (minimal overhang); from the 35 up, the machines are zero tail swing. Even the flagship 60 keeps a reduced tail swing (a 4-foot-3-inch radius) rather than going full conventional โ unusual for a 6-tonne machine.
The practical takeaway: with John Deere, you don’t agonize over tail swing the way you might with a brand that offers both. Every machine is built for close-quarters work near buildings, fences, and property lines. Your decision is really about size, dig depth, and hydraulics โ which is what the rest of this guide covers. (If you specifically need maximum open-field lifting stability and don’t value tight-quarters access, a conventional-tail-swing machine from another brand might edge out the Deere โ but for the prairie mix of drainage, residential, and acreage work, reduced/zero tail swing is usually an advantage.)
Question 1: What Size and Dig Depth Do You Need?
Size is the broadest cut, and it maps to dig depth, power, and price. The professional rule: choose a machine with a maximum dig depth at least 2 feet greater than your deepest realistic trench, so you’re not working at the machine’s limit.
Micro (1.7 Tonne): Tight Access
The 17 P-Tier (17G) is the smallest โ a 1.7-tonne machine with a hydraulically retractable, variable-width undercarriage that fits through gates and narrow paths, then expands for stability. With about 7 feet of dig depth, it’s built for landscaping, light utility, and tight-access work where fitting in is the priority. It’s too small to be a primary farm digger, but invaluable for confined jobs and a strong rental machine.
Small (2.7 to 3 Tonne): Versatile Light Work
The 26 P-Tier (26G) is a 2.7-tonne machine with about 8.5 feet of dig depth โ versatile for landscaping and detailed construction, moderate enough for most rental fleets. The 30 P-Tier (30G) fills the gap to the 35, a 3-tonne machine with about 9 feet of dig depth and more bucket, arm, and breakout force than the 26 โ a flexible step up that’s still easy to haul.
Mid-Size (3.6 Tonne): The Popular Workhorse
The 35 P-Tier (35G) is the heart of the lineup โ a 3.6-tonne zero-tail-swing machine with 10 feet of dig depth and about 17 feet of reach, powerful enough to dig out 24-inch tree stumps yet light enough to trailer easily. It’s one of the most popular compact excavators in its class, and for most prairie drainage, footing, and landscaping work, it’s the default choice. Its direct rivals are the Bobcat E35 and Kubota U35-4.
Large (5 to 6.1 Tonne): Serious Muscle
When the 35 runs out of capacity, the large machines step up โ and the jump is significant. The 50 P-Tier (50G) is a 5-tonne machine with 35.9 horsepower, nearly 12 feet of dig depth, close to 20 feet of reach, and considerably more breakout force and stability than the 35. The flagship 60 P-Tier (60G) is a 6.1-tonne machine with 53 horsepower, 12.4 feet of dig depth (13.6 with a long arm), an 8,550 lb lift capacity, and 50% more bucket breakout force than the 35 โ enough for demolition, deep foundations, and heavy material handling.
The rough dig-depth ladder: 17 ~7 ft, 26 ~8.5 ft, 30 ~9 ft, 35 ~10 ft, 50 ~11.6 ft, 60 ~12.4 ft. For the core of prairie excavator work โ tile drainage, water lines, footings โ the 35 through 50 range covers most needs.
Question 2: The Hydraulics Difference That Separates Small from Large
This is the most overlooked decision in John Deere’s lineup, and it genuinely changes how a machine performs with attachments โ worth understanding before you buy.
The smaller John Deere compact excavators (through the 35) use an open-center hydraulic system. In open-center, oil flows through all the valves in series; when you operate multiple functions at once, they compete for flow. The practical effect: the 35 can stall or lose performance when you run a demanding attachment (like a mulcher or brush cutter) while also moving the arm, because it prioritizes flow to individual functions.
The larger machines โ the 50 and 60 โ use a closed-center load-sensing hydraulic system with a variable-displacement pump. This delivers oil where it’s needed on demand, giving smooth, consistent multi-function performance. Running a brush cutter while slewing, or a thumb while curling the bucket, behaves far better on the 50 and 60 than on the 35.
The takeaway: if attachment-heavy or multi-function work (mulching, brush cutting, running a thumb constantly) is central to your operation, the 50 or 60’s closed-center hydraulics are a real advantage โ enough that some buyers step up from the 35 specifically for this. If you’re mostly digging and trenching with a bucket, the 35’s open-center system is perfectly capable and more economical. This single difference is often the deciding factor between the 35 and the 50.
Question 3: Engine and Emissions โ Note the Flagship Difference
John Deere’s compact excavators run Yanmar diesels, and there’s one emissions distinction worth knowing.
Most of the lineup โ including the popular 35 โ uses naturally aspirated Yanmar engines that meet Tier 4 Final emissions without aftertreatment devices (no diesel particulate filter). That’s a genuine advantage: no DPF means no regeneration cycles interrupting work and lower maintenance cost, valuable on a hard-working machine.
The exception is the flagship 60 P-Tier, which uses a larger turbo-adjacent Yanmar with a DPF (its exhaust points upward, and you won’t see the soot a non-DPF machine can emit). It’s still simple and well-supported, but it adds the DPF to the maintenance picture. If avoiding a DPF matters to you, the 35 and 50 keep it simple; the 60 trades that for its extra power. Confirm the emissions setup on any specific machine with your dealer.
Question 4: Attachments and Couplers
All six John Deere compact excavators share a common attachment system โ a real benefit if you already run John Deere equipment, since buckets and attachments carry across the fleet.
Standard auxiliary selector valves (on the 26 through 60) let you run one-way or two-way hydraulic attachments and switch between flows. For attachment changes, John Deere offers a wear-compensating wedge-style mechanical quick coupler (tighten it as it wears), plus optional pin-grabber and hydraulic wedge-lock couplers โ the pin-grabber lets you hook a bucket backwards to dig under sidewalks and utilities. The 26 and up are also compatible with engcon tiltrotators (which rotate 360 degrees and tilt 45 degrees side to side), and the 50 and 60 support EC-Oil for connecting and disconnecting the tiltrotator from the cab.
If you’ll run a hydraulic thumb constantly plus other attachments, spec a second auxiliary line โ the first runs the thumb, the second handles the other tool, so you’re not reducing pressure to share one circuit. Match your attachment plans to the machine’s hydraulic capability before buying.
Putting It Together: Quick Recommendations
Working through the questions, here’s where most buyers land:
- Tight-access landscaping and light utility:ย John Deere 17 P-Tierย (retractable, fits through gates).
- Versatile light work, rental-friendly:ย John Deere 26 P-Tierย or the more capableย 30 P-Tier.
- The prairie all-rounder (drainage, footings, stumps):ย John Deere 35 P-Tierย โ popular, zero tail swing, easy to haul.
- Attachment-heavy work (mulching, brush cutting):ย John Deere 50 P-Tierย โ closed-center hydraulics handle multi-function work smoothly.
- Deep digging, demolition, heavy lifting:ย John Deere 60 P-Tierย โ the flagship, maximum capability.
Full John Deere Compact Excavator Comparison Chart
Here’s the entire John Deere compact excavator lineup in one view, from micro to flagship. Model numbers are shown in current P-Tier form with the G-Series equivalent โ remember, for each size the G and P-Tier are essentially the same machine.
| Model | Class | Tail Swing | HP | Dig Depth | Hydraulics | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17 P-Tier (17G) | 1.7 t | Reduced + retractable | ~14.5 | ~7 ft 2 in | Open-center | Fits through gates, no DPF |
| 26 P-Tier (26G) | 2.7 t | Reduced | ~20 | ~8 ft 6 in | Open-center | Versatile, rental-friendly, no DPF |
| 30 P-Tier (30G) | 3 t | Reduced/zero | ~23 | ~9 ft 2 in | Open-center | Fills 26โ35 gap, no DPF |
| 35 P-Tier (35G) | 3.6 t | Zero | 23.3 | ~10 ft 0 in | Open-center | Popular workhorse, no DPF |
| 50 P-Tier (50G) | 5 t | Zero | 35.9 | ~11 ft 7 in | Closed-center | Smoother attachments, no DPF |
| 60 P-Tier (60G) | 6.1 t | Reduced | 53 | ~12 ft 4 in | Closed-center | Flagship, 8,550 lb lift, has DPF |
Comparing John Deere to Bobcat and Kubota
This guide focuses on choosing within the John Deere lineup, but most prairie buyers also cross-shop Bobcat and Kubota. John Deere’s edge is its reduced/zero-tail-swing-by-design approach across the whole line and its no-DPF engines on most models. The comparisons line up by size and tail swing: the zero-tail-swing 35 P-Tier against the zero-tail-swing Bobcat E35 and Kubota U35-4 โ the three most popular zero-tail-swing 3.5-tonne machines โ and the 60 P-Tier against the Bobcat E60 and Kubota KX057-5. For the full category picture across brands, see the Compact & Mini Excavatorshub on Aglist.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a John Deere 35G the same as a 35 P-Tier?
Essentially yes. John Deere is transitioning its lineup from “G-Series” to “P-Tier” naming, and for each size the two refer to essentially the same machine โ a 35G and a 35 P-Tier are the same 3.6-tonne, zero-tail-swing, 10-foot-dig-depth excavator. P-Tier versions have the latest cab and tech updates, but the core machine is the same. Dealers currently sell both, and a used “35G” is the same machine now called the “35 P-Tier.”
Which John Deere excavator is the most popular?
The 35 P-Tier (35G) is one of the most popular compact excavators in its class. Its 3.6-tonne size, zero tail swing, 10-foot dig depth, and easy transport make it the default choice for a huge share of drainage, footing, and landscaping work. For heavier needs, the 50 P-Tier and flagship 60 P-Tier are also popular, especially in rental fleets.
What is the biggest John Deere compact excavator?
The 60 P-Tier (60G) โ a 6.1-tonne flagship with 53 horsepower, a 12-foot-4-inch dig depth (13-foot-6 with the long arm), an 8,550 lb lift capacity, and 9,240 lb of bucket breakout force. It has 50% more breakout and dramatically more lifting than the 35, making it suitable for demolition and deep foundation work, while keeping a reduced tail swing for maneuverability.
Should I buy a John Deere 35 or 50?
It depends on your work and attachments. The 35 P-Tier is lighter, easier to haul, fits through a 6-foot gate, and has no emissions aftertreatment โ ideal for tight spaces and frequent transport. The 50 P-Tier has considerably more breakout force, more stability, more reach for loading trucks, and โ critically โ a closed-center load-sensing hydraulic system that handles multi-function attachment work (mulching, brush cutting) far better than the 35’s open-center system. If attachment-heavy work is central, the 50 is worth the step up; if you’re mostly bucket digging, the 35 is more economical.
Do John Deere compact excavators have a DPF?
Most don’t. The 17 through 50 use naturally aspirated Yanmar engines that meet Tier 4 Final emissions without aftertreatment devices โ no diesel particulate filter, no regeneration cycles, lower maintenance. The exception is the flagship 60 P-Tier, which uses a DPF. If avoiding a DPF matters to you, the 35 and 50 keep it simple.
What size John Deere excavator do I need for drainage and footings?
For tile drainage, water lines, and footings โ the core of prairie excavator work โ the 35 P-Tier (10-foot dig depth) handles most jobs, following the rule of choosing a machine with about 2 feet more depth than your target. For deeper trenching or tougher soil, step up to the 50 P-Tier (11.6 feet) or 60 P-Tier (12.4 feet).
Why does John Deere use reduced or zero tail swing on all its compact excavators?
It’s a design philosophy: rather than offering separate tight-tail and conventional series (as some competitors do), John Deere builds reduced or zero tail swing into nearly every compact machine so they all excel at close-quarters work near buildings, fences, and property lines. The 17 and 26 use reduced tail swing; the 35 and up are zero tail swing; even the flagship 60 keeps a reduced tail swing rather than going full conventional. It simplifies the buying decision and suits the mix of residential, drainage, and acreage work common on the prairies.
How does a John Deere 35 compare to a Bobcat E35 and Kubota U35-4?
All three are 3.5-tonne, zero-tail-swing machines with about 10 feet of dig depth โ the three most popular in the class. The 35 P-Tier offers Deere’s no-DPF Yanmar engine and dealer network; the Bobcat E35 offers an extendable arm and in-track swing frame; the Kubota U35-4 offers Kubota’s sales-leading reliability. The decision often comes down to dealer support, specific features, and price.
Note: We try our best to keep specs and information accurate, but some details can be missing or different depending on the source. Before you buy, service, or repair equipment, please double-check key specs with the manufacturer, the owner’s manual, or your dealer.
About reviews: Reviews on Aglist are written by real users. We moderate them for spam and abuse, but opinions and claims are still personalโso use them as guidance, not as a guarantee.
